How to Hire a Pinterest Manager (and Get It Right the First Time)

Table of Contents

Hiring a Pinterest manager sounds simple until you invest time and money into the wrong one and see little to no return.

I’ve seen this happen again and again. Business owners hire support expecting growth, only to feel confused, disappointed, or unsure if anything actually worked. Not because they didn’t care but because Pinterest is widely misunderstood, and most hiring advice leaves out the parts that actually matter.

I’m coming at this from both sides.

I ran a Pinterest management agency for years, and now I help business owners hire and work successfully with vetted Pinterest managers through matchmaking and consultation. I’ve also coached and mentored 70+ Pinterest managers and strategists, so I’ve seen exactly what works and what goes wrong from every angle.

And here’s what I can tell you: it’s rarely just about hiring the “wrong” person.
Business owners hire too early—or for the wrong reasons

Expectations and goals aren’t clearly defined

Great Pinterest managers struggle in the wrong environment

Decisions get made based on price instead of fit

The result? A frustrating experience that feels like a waste of money. I want to cover an end to end guide for Pinterest manager services from the hiring side.

If you’ve ever wondered:

  • Do I actually need a Pinterest manager?
  • What should I look for when hiring one?
  • How do I know if they’re the right fit or just confident?
  • What questions should I be asking before I hire?

You’re in the right place. If you’re a business owner (think shop owner, creator, coach or brand) thinking about hiring a Pinterest manager, you will want to read this before you book that discovery call.

By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly when it makes sense to hire a Pinterest manager (and when it doesn’t), how to choose someone who’s actually the right fit for your business, and what needs to be in place to make sure the investment leads to real results not just activity. You’ll also learn how to avoid the common mistakes that lead to frustration, wasted money, and unclear ROI—so you can move forward with confidence.

Alt text: "Pinterest Manager Hiring Guide cover with a smartphone displaying a Pinterest search for 'neutral living room.' Overlay text offers tips on hiring a Pinterest manager. Tone is professional and informative."

Because hiring a Pinterest manager can be one of the highest-ROI decisions you make in your business… but only if you do it right.

What Does a Pinterest Manager Do?

A Pinterest manager helps grow your business by creating and managing a search-driven content strategy on Pinterest. This includes keyword research, pin design, publishing, and ongoing optimization to drive traffic, leads, and sales over time.

Should You Hire a Pinterest Manager?

You should consider hiring a Pinterest manager if you have consistent content, a clear offer, and want to turn Pinterest into a long-term traffic source.

You should not hire one if you don’t yet have a funnel, content, or validated offer—because Pinterest amplifies what already exists.

Before You Hire: What Pinterest Managers Actually Do

Hiring decisions go wrong all the time. Who hasn’t been fooled by nice marketing at least once?

If I’ve seen it once, I’ve seen it hundreds of times:
“I hired a Pinterest manager… and it didn’t work for me.”

So before you hire anyone, we need to get clear on the basics of what a Pinterest manager is actually responsible for—because this is where most of the disconnect starts. You need to understand the work, goals and what’s realistic for the service provider you hire.

A Pinterest Manager Is Not Just “Posting Pins”

A Pinterest manager helps businesses grow traffic and visibility through Pinterest’s search and discovery system by managing:

  • Platform specific strategy
  • Content creation
  • Publishing (cadence, distribution, and optimization)
  • Ongoing performance tracking and refinement

This distinction—strategy + execution over time is what separates effective Pinterest management from simple Pin scheduling.

A Pinterest manager helps businesses grow traffic and visibility through Pinterest’s search and discovery system by managing strategy, content creation, publishing, and ongoing optimization over time.

What a Good Pinterest Manager Is Actually Building

Beyond the day-to-day work (tasks), a Pinterest manager is building a search-driven visibility system for your business.

This system is designed to:

  • Help the right people discover your content (intent)
  • Drive consistent, qualified traffic (growth)
  • Support long-term growth over time (sustainability)

Behind the scenes, this requires more than just Pinterest knowledge. A strong manager understands how content, conversions, website experience, and search behavior all work together.

Because Pinterest functions more like a search engine than a social platform, results come from consistent, strategic effort—not one-off activity.

The Skillset Behind the best pinterest managers

A strong Pinterest manager isn’t just “good at Pinterest.”

They understand:

  • content strategy
  • conversion pathways
  • website experience
  • search behavior

Because all of these influence whether Pinterest traffic actually does anything for your business.

Woman in a green sweater sits on a couch with a laptop. Text reads "What to Know Before You Hire a Pinterest Manager." Website link below.

Core responsibilities of a Pinterest manager (What exactly do they do?)

In simple terms: a Pinterest manager sets up, creates, and continuously optimizes your account so your content gets found—and keeps getting found.

While services vary, most Pinterest managers are responsible for building and optimizing your account so Pinterest can understand, categorize, and distribute your content to the right people.

While services vary, most Pinterest managers are responsible for building and optimizing your account so Pinterest can understand, categorize, and distribute your content


When It Makes Sense to Hire a Pinterest Manager (And When It Doesn’t)

Hiring a Pinterest manager can absolutely accelerate your growth.

But only if the foundation is there.

Otherwise, you’re paying someone to manage… nothing.

A woman works on a laptop in a cozy room with a staircase and plant. Text reads: "How to Hire a Pinterest Manager the Right Way!" Calm and focused mood.

When It Does Make Sense to Hire a Pinterest Manager

You already have content (or a way to create it consistently)

Pinterest needs something to work with:

  • Blog posts
  • Product pages
  • Lead magnets or separate landing pages
  • YouTube videos
  • Third party products listings

If you have a steady stream of content or even a solid backlog a Pinterest manager can turn that into a traffic engine.

No content, no links = nothing to distribute + keep the platform happy and growing

You understand your offer and how you make money (Funnel)

This is a big one that so many who are new to Pinterest miss. Pinterest drives traffic.
But traffic only matters if it has somewhere to go. If you are looking to promote something on Pinterest, we do assume you have a monetization model set up and know how you are making money.

You’re in a good place to hire if:

  • You know your core offers
  • You’re not still “figuring out your business model”
  • You have a clear customer journey (even a simple one)
  • Have converted via the funnel before beginning on Pinterest

You’re already seeing some traction (even small wins) with pinterest

You don’t need massive results or numbers but you do need to have some results. I think this ensures you aren’t just “testing” Pinterest before investing a lot of money into hiring someone. Now if you are in a position to spend money and not too worried about ROI, go for it but most business owners want to know they can garner results when hiring a service provider.

But signs like:

…mean there’s something to build on. A Pinterest manager can optimize and scale what’s already working. Now what I will share is that often businesses will approach me that have never used Pinterest but have a well developed marketing plan and social presence elsewhere. This can work too but remember, Pinterest does require patience and can take awhile to build up results and ROI.

You don’t have the time (or desire) to manage it yourself

Pinterest does require:

  • Consistency
  • Testing
  • Ongoing optimization and adjustments

If you could do it but realistically won’t… that’s a valid reason to outsource the work to a great Pinterest manager.

You’re thinking long-term (not quick wins)

I can’t say this enough, Pinterest is the long game. It isn’t going to be an overnight success so if you need immediate results, Pinterest is NOT the platform for you.


If you’re looking for:

  • Immediate leads or sales
  • Fast cash
  • Overnight growth
  • A quick fix

Hiring a Pinterest manager will feel disappointing and likely not end well for you.

What to Look For in a Pinterest Manager

A good Pinterest manager combines strategy, execution, and ongoing optimization.

Look for someone who:

  • Understands Pinterest SEO and keyword strategy
  • Connects content to business goals
  • Has a clear process and workflow
  • Can explain results beyond impressions

When It Doesn’t Make Sense to hire a pinterest manager or strategist (Yet)

This is where most people jump too soon. Too many rush to conclusions without being informed of when it does not make sense to hire a Pinterest service provider.

You don’t have content or a place to send traffic

No blog. No lead magnet. No real landing pages. Maybe no website. You have nothing to claim as yours (a website or your Instagram) on your business page. This is problematic because then we cannot use the full analytics to track events and conversions.

Even if someone drives traffic… it is less likely convert. And if it does convert, we won’t be able to attribute it to Pinterest.

Fix this first. Establish your base/foundation before hiring someone to manage your Pinterest account.

You’re unclear on your niche or audience

If your messaging is:

  • Broad
  • Inconsistent
  • Still evolving

Pinterest strategy becomes guesswork. And no manager can fix a positioning problem.

You’re expecting the manager to “figure it all out”

A Pinterest manager is not:

  • Your business strategist
  • Your offer creator
  • Your conversion specialist

They amplify what exists. They can identify if something isn’t working or needs attention but as Pinterest marketing specialists, they focus their time and efforts on what they can control. A wonderful, robust service provider will be looking at your content, products, messaging and funnel to ensure they are creating a great Pinterest strategy but then you need to work together (collaborate) on making adjustments and tweaks to get the most out of your Pinterest growth.

They don’t build your business from scratch.

You’re not ready to invest consistently or are stressed by outsourcing tasks

Pinterest works best with:

  • Ongoing content creation to support growth (this includes fresh links on your website)
  • Monthly management (30 day time blocks, 3 months to start to get things moving in the right direction)
  • Time to test and refine (this typically happens in months 2+3 when you first start)

If you’re hiring for a one-month “trial” hoping for big results…You’re setting yourself up for frustration. If you are on a tight budget, I would suggest understanding Pinterest at a basic level yourself before outsourcing it and consider a course or program like Pin Potential. This will empower you to understand the strategy before hiring.

You haven’t validated your offer or products yet

If you haven’t made sales (or very few): more cold traffic won’t fix that. It usually just magnifies the problem. Work on making sales organically and understanding the sales journey and pipeline before hiring a Pinterest manager.

Alt text: "Text overlay reading 'The Truth About Hiring a Pinterest Manager' on a blurred background featuring Pinterest-related graphics. Website URL at the bottom."

My Honest Take + advice as a pinterest expert

A Pinterest manager is a multiplier.

  • Good foundation → better results
  • Weak foundation → faster disappointment

If you’re ready, it can save you time and accelerate growth.

If you’re not, the smartest move is to focus on:

  • Your content
  • Your offers (funnel)
  • Your strategy

Then bring in support when there’s something worth scaling.

A person holds a smartphone with the text, "Is hiring a Pinterest manager worth it for small businesses?" and a "Learn More" button above.

How to Choose the Right Pinterest Manager for Your Business

This is where a lot of people go wrong.

They hire based on:

  • Pretty Pins
  • A nice Instagram feed
  • Flashy marketing
  • Or a “feels good” conversation

None of those things guarantee results.

If you want Pinterest to actually work as a marketing channel, you need to choose someone who understands how to build a search-driven system—not just someone who can make things look good.

Let’s break down what that actually looks like.

What to Look For in a Pinterest Manager

You’re not just hiring a doer. You’re hiring a strategist and an executor. If you want to hire someone to just fill your queue, you can hire a VA and have them do that. But you want Pinterest to work for you, so you aren’t going to do that. Freelance Pinterest manager are a wonderful asset to your marketing growth. They are your Pinterest marketing manager.

Here’s what actually matters:

1. They talk about strategy first—not posting
They should be asking about:

  • Your business goals
  • Your offers
  • Your content
  • Your audience

If the conversation jumps straight to “how many Pins per day”… that’s a red flag. We have long let go of the “perfect” number of Pins for all accounts. The number varies. We focus on sharing as much as we need to post to create growth and results.

2. They understand Pinterest SEO and keywords
Pinterest runs on search.

They should clearly explain:

  • How they do keyword research
  • How they choose topics
  • How they align content with search intent

If keywords aren’t part of their process, they’re missing the foundation.

3. They connect Pinterest to business results
A strong manager doesn’t just talk about:

  • Impressions
  • Saves

They talk about:

  • Clicks
  • Traffic
  • Conversions
  • Next steps for improvements

Because visibility without action doesn’t grow a business.

4. They have a clear process (not vibes)
They should be able to walk you through:

  • Their onboarding
  • Their monthly workflow
  • Their optimization process
  • Transparent timeline and what to expect

You want a system—not guesswork.

5. They think beyond Pinterest
The best Pinterest managers understand:

  • Your website
  • Your content funnel
  • Your customer journey

Because Pinterest traffic only works if it has somewhere useful to go.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire

Don’t be afraid to ask direct questions.

You’re making an investment—you should understand exactly what you’re getting.

Start here:

Strategy + Approach

  • How would you approach Pinterest strategy for my business specifically?
  • How do you decide what content we should create or prioritize?
  • What role do keywords play in your process?
  • Do they have experience in your niche or a related one?

Execution + Deliverables

  • What’s included in your monthly management?
  • How many Pins will be created and published to start? Will this change?
  • Do you create content, or work from existing assets?
  • How often will you touch base and provide reporting?

Results + Measurement

  • What metrics do you track regularly?
  • How do you define success on Pinterest?
  • Can you share examples of past client results?
  • What will our agreed upon goals be each month?
  • What is the benchmark goal for growth month over month?

Communication + Fit

  • What do you need from me to make this successful?
  • How often will we communicate?
  • What does onboarding look like?
  • What will you need from me month to month?

If someone struggles to answer these clearly, it’s not a small issue—it usually means there’s no real process behind the work and strategy. Good Pinterest managers will love that you are asking questions, getting specific and want to set goals.

The bottom line when choosing a pinterest manager or strategist

Choosing the right Pinterest manager isn’t about finding someone who can “do Pinterest.”

It’s about finding someone who understands:

  • How people search
  • How content gets discovered
  • And how that discovery turns into real business results
  • Asks thoughtful questions about your business so they can help you grow

That’s the difference between:
Paying for activity and investing in growth

And once you see that difference, you won’t unsee it.

Red Flags to Avoid When Hiring a Pinterest manager

A good pinterest manager does not:

Guarantee overnight sales or instant results
Pinterest is a long-game platform. Results compound over weeks and months—not days. You can expect meaningful traction to take 60–90 days. If you want a realistic picture, read this blog post about the Pinterest timeline for results.

Replace your funnel or offer strategy
A Pinterest manager isn’t there to fix a broken or leaky funnel (though a good one will flag issues quickly).

Pinterest can drive qualified traffic—but it won’t magically:

  • fix unclear messaging or positioning
  • create demand where none exists
  • turn a weak website into a sales machine
  • repair a broken checkout or email flow
  • make an unvalidated offer profitable

If you don’t already have:

  • something to sell
  • a clear path from traffic → action
  • or proof your offer converts (even organically)

Pinterest won’t fix that for you.

What it does do exceptionally well is amplify what’s already working—by sending consistent, search-based traffic into a funnel that makes sense.

That’s why a strong Pinterest manager will ask about:

  • your offers
  • your landing pages
  • your email or sales process
  • other marketing channels and conversion data

Not to overstep—but to ensure the traffic they send can actually convert and be measured.

Act like a social media manager
Pinterest managers are not focused on daily engagement, comments, or trends. Their role is search visibility and long-term discovery. There is no need for them to login daily.

Hiring a Pinterest Manager: What to Expect

Most people don’t realize this until it’s too late: Hiring a Pinterest manager is not the same as hiring a social media manager.

Pinterest isn’t about posting one thing a day, responding to comments or chasing engagement. It’s a search platform. A long-term traffic driver. A system that—when done right—can quietly send people to your business for months (or even years) after something is published.

And that’s exactly where expectations get misaligned.

So let’s get clear on what real Pinterest results look like.

The First 90 Days: Laying the Foundation with your pinterest manager

In the beginning, the focus is not explosive growth.

It’s:

  • Setting up or optimizing your account
  • Building keyword-driven content
  • Publishing consistently with intention
  • Sending the right signals to Pinterest

You may start to see:

  • Increased impressions
  • Early saves on content
  • Some clicks

This phase is about building the foundation (profile) and momentum not judging ROI or results. We don’t typically see sales in the first 60 days of a new account.

3–6 Months: Traction and Data with your pinterest manager

This is where things start to shift.

Your content begins to:

  • Show up in search
  • Get discovered more consistently
  • Drive more clicks to your site

You’ll also start to see:

  • Patterns in what content works
  • More consistent outbound traffic
  • Opportunities to optimize and double down

This is where Pinterest starts becoming useful—not just visible.

6+ Months: Compounding Growth from working with your pinterest manager

This is the goal.

At this stage, Pinterest becomes a reliable traffic source that works in the background of your business. This is when you start to see what’s really possible. Some businesses owners even report the real “story” emerges at the one year mark.

You may see:

  • Consistent, predictable traffic
  • Growth in your email list or sales
  • Content continuing to perform long after it’s published

This is where Pinterest shifts from effort → asset.

What Pinterest Will Not Do (On Its Own)

Let’s be honest for a second.

Pinterest will not:

  • Fix a weak offer
  • Build your funnel for you
  • Convert traffic without a clear next step (remember this is a cold audience but they do have intent to FIND YOU)

A Pinterest manager can drive the right people to your content…but your business still needs to convert them. If you are interested in how to become a Pinterest manager, check out my mini course.

THe bottom life?

Pinterest results are not instant—but they are powerful.

When done right, you’re not just posting content.
You’re building a system that attracts the right audience, works over time, and continues to support your business long after the work is done.

That’s the difference between short-term marketing—and long-term growth.

Pinterest isn’t about doing more. It’s about building something that works.

And when you hire the right person—with the right foundation in place—it becomes one of the most reliable growth channels in your business.

Not overnight—but consistently, predictably, and over time.

A woman smiles while looking at her phone, sitting next to a table. Text overlay reads, "A Complete Guide to Hiring a Pinterest Manager for Your Business."

Need Help Finding the Right Pinterest Manager?

Finding someone who actually understands Pinterest strategy isn’t always easy. If you’re serious about hiring a Pinterest manager—and want to skip the guesswork—you can reach out below.

I’ve personally vetted and trained a network of Pinterest managers I trust—and I’m happy to help match you with the right fit.

I’ll help match you with someone who:

  • fits your business and goals
  • aligns with your budget
  • and actually understands Pinterest strategy
  • I have personally trained, vetted and trust

Submit your details below and I’ll point you in the right direction of a few wonderful Pinterest managers (no cost).

Frequently Asked Questions About Hiring a Pinterest Manager

How much does a Pinterest manager cost?

Pinterest management typically ranges from $500 to $3,000+ per month (USD) depending on scope, experience, and deliverables. Pinterest manager rates vary from service provider to service provider.

How long does it take to see results from Pinterest?

Most businesses begin seeing traction within 60–90 days, with stronger, compounding results after 3–6 months. I have a blog post about it here

Is hiring a Pinterest manager worth it?

It can be a high-ROI investment if you have the right foundation in place. A Pinterest manager amplifies existing content and drives long-term traffic.

How can I make sure I hire the right Pinterest manager?

To hire the right Pinterest manager, look beyond visuals and focus on strategy.

A strong Pinterest manager should:
Ask questions about your business, offers, and goals
Explain their keyword and content strategy clearly
Connect Pinterest efforts to traffic and conversions
Have a defined process for onboarding, reporting, and optimization
Most importantly, they should be able to explain why they’re doing something—not just what they’re doing.

What’s normal when you first start working with a Pinterest manager?

Most Pinterest managers recommend working together for at least 3 months.
This initial period is used to:
Set up or optimize your account
Build keyword-driven content
Start publishing consistently
Gather data on what’s working
Pinterest is a long-term platform, so early work focuses on building a foundation—not immediate results.

Can a Pinterest manager guarantee results?

No. Pinterest is a long-term platform, and results depend on your content, offer, and consistency.

Pinterest Manager vs Social Media Manager

A Pinterest manager focuses on search, traffic, and long-term visibility.
A social media manager focuses on engagement, posting frequency, and short-term content performance.

Should I hire a Pinterest manager with experience in my niche?

Not necessarily.
While niche experience can be helpful, it’s not required. A skilled Pinterest manager understands:
how to research keywords
how to identify search intent
how to create and test content across industries
In many cases, strong strategy and adaptability matter more than niche-specific experience.

How do I know if my Pinterest manager is doing a good job?

A good Pinterest manager should show progress over time—not just activity.
Look for:
increasing clicks and traffic (not just impressions)
clear reporting and insights
ongoing testing and optimization
communication about what’s working and what’s changing
Pinterest results take time, but you should see momentum and direction, not confusion.

Leave a Comment